N°9723 - IsActionAllowed should work with non instantiated users objects (#947)

* Replace references to user objects keys since objects can be non-instantiated (so no key available) and replace them by equivalent code

* Rename test + use self variable for profile

---------

Co-authored-by: jf-cbd <jf-cbd@users.noreply.github.com>

addons/userrights/userrightsprofile.class.inc.php

@@ -582,16 +582,26 @@ class UserRightsProfile extends UserRightsAddOnAPI
 	 */
 	public function ListProfiles($oUser)
 	{
-		$aRet = [];
-		$oSearch = new DBObjectSearch('URP_UserProfile');
-		$oSearch->AllowAllData();
-		$oSearch->NoContextParameters();
-		$oSearch->Addcondition('userid', $oUser->GetKey(), '=');
-		$oProfiles = new DBObjectSet($oSearch);
-		while ($oUserProfile = $oProfiles->Fetch()) {
-			$aRet[$oUserProfile->Get('profileid')] = $oUserProfile->Get('profileid_friendlyname');
+		if (count($oUser->ListChanges()) === 0) { // backward compatibility
+			$aRet = [];
+			$oSearch = new DBObjectSearch('URP_UserProfile');
+			$oSearch->AllowAllData();
+			$oSearch->NoContextParameters();
+			$oSearch->Addcondition('userid', $oUser->GetKey(), '=');
+			$oProfiles = new DBObjectSet($oSearch);
+			while ($oUserProfile = $oProfiles->Fetch()) {
+				$aRet[$oUserProfile->Get('profileid')] = $oUserProfile->Get('profileid_friendlyname');
+			}
+
+			return $aRet;
+		} else {
+			$aRet = [];
+			$oProfilesSet = $oUser->Get('profile_list');
+			foreach ($oProfilesSet as $oUserProfile) {
+				$aRet[$oUserProfile->Get('profileid')] = $oUserProfile->Get('profileid_friendlyname');
+			}
+			return $aRet;
 		}
-		return $aRet;
 	}
 
 	public function GetSelectFilter($oUser, $sClass, $aSettings = [])
@@ -705,26 +715,23 @@ class UserRightsProfile extends UserRightsAddOnAPI
 	protected function GetUserActionGrant($oUser, $sClass, $iActionCode)
 	{
 		$this->LoadCache();
-
-		// load and cache permissions for the current user on the given class
-		//
-		$iUser = $oUser->GetKey();
-		if (isset($this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$iUser][$sClass][$iActionCode])) {
-			$aTest = $this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$iUser][$sClass][$iActionCode];
-			if (is_array($aTest)) {
-				return $aTest;
+		if (count($oUser->ListChanges()) === 0) {
+			// load and cache permissions for the current user on the given class
+			if (isset($this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$oUser->GetKey()][$sClass][$iActionCode])) {
+				$aTest = $this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$oUser->GetKey()][$sClass][$iActionCode];
+				if (is_array($aTest)) {
+					return $aTest;
+				}
 			}
 		}
 
 		$sAction = self::$m_aActionCodes[$iActionCode];
 
 		$bStatus = null;
-		// Cache user's profiles
-		if (false === array_key_exists($iUser, $this->aUsersProfilesList)) {
-			$this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser] = UserRights::ListProfiles($oUser);
-		}
+
+		$aProfileList = $this->GetProfileList($oUser);
 		// Call the API of UserRights because it caches the list for us
-		foreach ($this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser] as $iProfile => $oProfile) {
+		foreach ($aProfileList as $iProfile => $oProfile) {
 			$bGrant = $this->GetProfileActionGrant($iProfile, $sClass, $sAction);
 			if (!is_null($bGrant)) {
 				if ($bGrant) {
@@ -742,7 +749,9 @@ class UserRightsProfile extends UserRightsAddOnAPI
 		$aRes = [
 			'permission' => $iPermission,
 		];
-		$this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$iUser][$sClass][$iActionCode] = $aRes;
+		if (count($oUser->ListChanges()) === 0) {
+			$this->m_aObjectActionGrants[$oUser->GetKey()][$sClass][$iActionCode] = $aRes;
+		}
 		return $aRes;
 	}
 
@@ -824,18 +833,14 @@ class UserRightsProfile extends UserRightsAddOnAPI
 	{
 		$this->LoadCache();
 		// Note: this code is VERY close to the code of IsActionAllowed()
-		$iUser = $oUser->GetKey();
 
-		// Cache user's profiles
-		if (false === array_key_exists($iUser, $this->aUsersProfilesList)) {
-			$this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser] = UserRights::ListProfiles($oUser);
-		}
+		$aProfileList  = $this->GetProfileList($oUser);
 
 		// Note: The object set is ignored because it was interesting to optimize for huge data sets
 		//       and acceptable to consider only the root class of the object set
 		$bStatus = null;
 		// Call the API of UserRights because it caches the list for us
-		foreach ($this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser] as $iProfile => $oProfile) {
+		foreach ($aProfileList as $iProfile => $oProfile) {
 			$bGrant = $this->GetClassStimulusGrant($iProfile, $sClass, $sStimulusCode);
 			if (!is_null($bGrant)) {
 				if ($bGrant) {
@@ -893,6 +898,25 @@ class UserRightsProfile extends UserRightsAddOnAPI
 		}
 		return $bHasSharing;
 	}
+
+	/**
+	 * @param \User $oUser
+	 *
+	 * @return array
+	 * @throws \Exception
+	 */
+	public function GetProfileList(User $oUser): array
+	{
+		if (count($oUser->ListChanges()) === 0) { // if user is already in db and not changed
+			$iUser = $oUser->GetKey();
+			if (false === array_key_exists($iUser, $this->aUsersProfilesList)) {
+				$aProfiles = UserRights::ListProfiles($oUser);
+				$this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser] = $aProfiles;
+			}
+			return $this->aUsersProfilesList[$iUser];
+		}
+		return UserRights::ListProfiles($oUser);
+	}
 }
 
 UserRights::SelectModule('UserRightsProfile');

core/userrights.class.inc.php

@@ -1530,6 +1530,37 @@ class UserRights
 		}
 	}
 
+	/**
+	 * @param User $oUser
+	 * @param array $aExcludedProfilesId Administrator by default, but can also be other proofiles depending on needs (e.g. power portal user or REST profile)
+	 * @return bool
+	 * @throws ArchivedObjectException
+	 * @throws CoreException
+	 * @throws CoreUnexpectedValue
+	 * @throws MySQLException
+	 */
+	public static function IsUserReadOnly(User $oUser, array $aExcludedProfilesId = [1]): bool
+	{
+		$oUserProfiles = $oUser->Get('profile_list');
+		$oUserRights = UserRights::GetModuleInstance();
+		while ($oUserProfile = $oUserProfiles->Fetch()) {
+			$iProfileId = $oUserProfile->Get('profileid');
+			if (in_array($iProfileId, $aExcludedProfilesId)) {
+				return false;
+			}
+			foreach (MetaModel::GetClasses('bizmodel,grant_by_profile') as $sClass) {
+				foreach (['w', 'bw', 'd', 'bd'] as $sWriteActionCode) {
+					$bIsGranted = $oUserRights->GetProfileActionGrant($iProfileId, $sClass, $sWriteActionCode);
+					if ($bIsGranted === true) {
+						return false;
+					}
+				}
+			}
+		}
+
+		return true;
+	}
+
 	/**
 	 * @param string $sClass
 	 * @param int $iActionCode see UR_ACTION_* constants

datamodels/2.x/itop-profiles-itil/datamodel.itop-profiles-itil.xml

@@ -85,6 +85,13 @@
           <class id="Attachment"/>
         </classes>
       </group>
+      <group id="Ticket" _delta="define">
+        <classes>
+          <class id="Ticket"/>
+          <class id="WorkOrder"/>
+          <class id="Attachment"/>
+        </classes>
+      </group>
       <group id="Portal" _delta="define">
         <classes>
           <class id="lnkFunctionalCIToTicket"/>
@@ -205,6 +212,60 @@
       </group>
     </groups>
     <profiles>
+      <profile id="5500" _delta="define">
+        <name>Configuration ReadOnly</name>
+        <description>This read-only profile allows to see CIs objects.</description>
+        <groups>
+          <group id="Configuration">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+          <group id="General">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+        </groups>
+      </profile>
+      <profile id="5501" _delta="define">
+        <name>Ticket ReadOnly</name>
+        <description>This read-only profile allows to see Ticket objects.</description>
+        <groups>
+          <group id="Ticket">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+          <group id="General">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+        </groups>
+      </profile>
+      <profile id="5502" _delta="define">
+        <name>Service Catalog ReadOnly</name>
+        <description>This read-only profile allows to see Service Catalog objects.</description>
+        <groups>
+          <group id="Service">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+          <group id="General">
+            <actions>
+              <action id="action:read">allow</action>
+              <action id="action:bulk read">allow</action>
+            </actions>
+          </group>
+        </groups>
+      </profile>
       <profile id="117" _delta="define">
         <name>SuperUser</name>
         <description>This profile allows all actions which are not Administrator restricted.</description>

datamodels/2.x/itop-structure/data/data.sample.users.xml

@@ -4,80 +4,64 @@
     <contactid>9</contactid>
     <email>jules.vernes@it.com</email>
     <org_id_friendlyname>IT Department</org_id_friendlyname>
-    <login>Agent</login>
+    <login>SupportAgent</login>
     <language>EN US</language>
     <status>disabled</status>
-    <profile_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserProfile id="5">
-          <profileid>5</profileid>
-          <profile>Support Agent</profile>
-          <reason></reason>
-        </URP_UserProfile>
-      </Set>
-    </profile_list>
-    <allowed_org_list>
-      <Set>
-      </Set>
-    </allowed_org_list>
-    <password><![CDATA[R6rQ;p]JT*FA$aaP^4]]></password>
+     <password><![CDATA[SupportAgent]]></password>
     <expiration>force_expire</expiration>
     <password_renewed_date>2026-06-04</password_renewed_date>
   </UserLocal>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="5">
+    <userid>4</userid>
+    <userlogin>SupportAgent</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='5'</profileid>
+    <profile>Support Agent</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
   <UserLocal alias="UserLocal" id="5">
     <contactid>26</contactid>
     <contactid_friendlyname>Jean Ferrat</contactid_friendlyname>
     <org_id_friendlyname>IT Department</org_id_friendlyname>
-    <login>config</login>
+    <login>ConfigManager</login>
     <language>EN US</language>
     <status>disabled</status>
-    <profile_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserProfile id="6">
-          <profileid>3</profileid>
-          <profile>Configuration Manager</profile>
-          <reason></reason>
-        </URP_UserProfile>
-      </Set>
-    </profile_list>
-    <allowed_org_list>
-      <Set>
-      </Set>
-    </allowed_org_list>
-    <password><![CDATA[$W[:"7+Gf"Y\sd8#E~]]></password>
+    <password><![CDATA[$W[ConfigManager]]></password>
     <expiration>force_expire</expiration>
     <password_renewed_date>2026-06-04</password_renewed_date>
   </UserLocal>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="6">
+    <userid>5</userid>
+    <userlogin>ConfigManager</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='3'</profileid>
+    <profile>Configuration Manager</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
   <UserLocal alias="UserLocal" id="2">
     <contactid>15</contactid>
     <email>agatha.christie@demo.com</email>
     <org_id_friendlyname>Sales Department</org_id_friendlyname>
-    <login>Portal</login>
+    <login>PortalUser</login>
     <language>EN US</language>
     <status>disabled</status>
-    <profile_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserProfile id="2">
-          <profileid>2</profileid>
-          <profile>Portal user</profile>
-          <reason></reason>
-        </URP_UserProfile>
-      </Set>
-    </profile_list>
-    <allowed_org_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserOrg id="2">
-          <allowed_org_id>6</allowed_org_id>
-          <allowed_org_name>Sales Department</allowed_org_name>
-          <reason></reason>
-          <allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>no</allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>
-        </URP_UserOrg>
-      </Set>
-    </allowed_org_list>
-    <password><![CDATA[-Why]KDdMJvkuB8#e]]></password>
+    <password><![CDATA[PortalUser]]></password>
     <expiration>force_expire</expiration>
     <password_renewed_date>2026-04-17</password_renewed_date>
   </UserLocal>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="2">
+    <userid>2</userid>
+    <userlogin>PortalUser</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='2'</profileid>
+    <profile>Portal user</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
+  <URP_UserOrg id="2">
+    <userid>2</userid>
+    <userlogin>PortalUser</userlogin>
+    <allowed_org_id>6</allowed_org_id>
+    <allowed_org_name>Sales Department</allowed_org_name>
+    <reason></reason>
+    <allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>no</allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>
+  </URP_UserOrg>
   <UserLocal alias="UserLocal" id="3">
     <contactid>6</contactid>
     <email>claude.monet@demo.com</email>
@@ -85,32 +69,48 @@
     <login>SalesManager</login>
     <language>EN US</language>
     <status>disabled</status>
-    <profile_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserProfile id="4">
-          <profileid>12</profileid>
-          <profile>Portal power user</profile>
-          <reason></reason>
-        </URP_UserProfile>
-        <URP_UserProfile id="3">
-          <profileid>2</profileid>
-          <profile>Portal user</profile>
-          <reason></reason>
-        </URP_UserProfile>
-      </Set>
-    </profile_list>
-    <allowed_org_list>
-      <Set>
-        <URP_UserOrg id="1">
-          <allowed_org_id>6</allowed_org_id>
-          <allowed_org_name>Sales Department</allowed_org_name>
-          <reason></reason>
-          <allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>no</allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>
-        </URP_UserOrg>
-      </Set>
-    </allowed_org_list>
-    <password><![CDATA[D%r7hoZ})5*hvq5`{Q]]></password>
+    <password><![CDATA[SalesManager]]></password>
     <expiration>force_expire</expiration>
     <password_renewed_date>2026-06-04</password_renewed_date>
   </UserLocal>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="4">
+    <userid>3</userid>
+    <userlogin>SalesManager</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='12'</profileid>
+    <profile>Portal power user</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="3">
+    <userid>3</userid>
+    <userlogin>SalesManager</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='2'</profileid>
+    <profile>Portal user</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
+  <URP_UserOrg id="1">
+    <userid>3</userid>
+    <userlogin>SalesManager</userlogin>
+    <allowed_org_id>6</allowed_org_id>
+    <allowed_org_name>Sales Department</allowed_org_name>
+    <reason></reason>
+    <allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>no</allowed_org_id_obsolescence_flag>
+  </URP_UserOrg>
+  <UserLocal alias="UserLocal" id="6">
+    <contactid>18</contactid>
+    <email>rene.descartes@demo.com</email>
+    <org_id_friendlyname>Demo</org_id_friendlyname>
+    <login>SuperUser</login>
+    <language>EN US</language>
+    <status>disabled</status>
+    <password><![CDATA[SuperUser]]></password>
+    <expiration>force_expire</expiration>
+    <password_renewed_date>2026-04-17</password_renewed_date>
+  </UserLocal>
+  <URP_UserProfile id="7">
+    <userid>6</userid>
+    <userlogin>SuperUser</userlogin>
+    <profileid>SELECT URP_Profiles WHERE id='117'</profileid>
+    <profile>Super User</profile>
+    <reason></reason>
+  </URP_UserProfile>
 </Set>

tests/php-unit-tests/src/BaseTestCase/ItopDataTestCase.php

@@ -87,8 +87,6 @@ abstract class ItopDataTestCase extends ItopTestCase
 	 */
 	public const DEFAULT_TEST_ENVIRONMENT = 'production';
 	public const USE_TRANSACTION = true;
-	public const CREATE_TEST_ORG = false;
-
 	protected static $aURP_Profiles = [
 		'Administrator'         => 1,
 		'Portal user'           => 2,
@@ -102,9 +100,15 @@ abstract class ItopDataTestCase extends ItopTestCase
 		'Service Manager'       => 10,
 		'Document author'       => 11,
 		'Portal power user'     => 12,
+		'Business partner user'     => 40,
 		'REST Services User'    => 1024,
+		'Configuration ReadOnly' => 5500,
+		'Ticket ReadOnly' => 5501,
+		'Service Catalog ReadOnly' => 5502,
 	];
 
+	public const CREATE_TEST_ORG = false;
+
 	/**
 	 * This method is called before the first test of this test class is run (in the current process).
 	 */
@@ -1463,16 +1467,42 @@ abstract class ItopDataTestCase extends ItopTestCase
 		]);
 	}
 
+	/**
+	 * @description To avoid adding finalclasses parameters to GivenUserInDB
+	 * @param string $sPassword
+	 * @param array $aProfiles Profile names Example: ['Administrator']
+	 * @param bool $bReturnLogin
+	 *
+	 * @return string|int The unique login
+	 * @throws \Exception
+	 */
+	protected function GivenTokenUserInDB(array $aProfiles, bool $bReturnLogin = true): string|int
+	{
+		$sLogin = 'demo_test_'.uniqid(__CLASS__, true);
+
+		$aProfileList = array_map(function ($sProfileId) {
+			return 'profileid:'.self::$aURP_Profiles[$sProfileId];
+		}, $aProfiles);
+
+		$iUser = $this->GivenObjectInDB('UserToken', [
+			'login' => $sLogin,
+			'language' => 'EN US',
+			'profile_list' => $aProfileList,
+		]);
+		return $bReturnLogin ? $sLogin : $iUser;
+	}
+
 	/**
 	 * @param string $sPassword
 	 * @param array $aProfiles Profile names Example: ['Administrator']
 	 * @param string|null $sLogin
 	 * @param string|null $sUserId
+	 * @param bool $bReturnLogin
 	 *
 	 * @return string The unique login
 	 * @throws \Exception
 	 */
-	protected function GivenUserInDB(string $sPassword, array $aProfiles, ?string $sLogin = null, ?string &$sUserId = null): string
+	protected function GivenUserInDB(string $sPassword, array $aProfiles, ?string $sLogin = null, ?string &$sUserId = null, bool $bReturnLogin = true): string
 	{
 		if (is_null($sLogin)) {
 			$sLogin = 'demo_test_'.uniqid(__CLASS__, true);
@@ -1489,7 +1519,7 @@ abstract class ItopDataTestCase extends ItopTestCase
 			'profile_list' => $aProfileList,
 		]);
 
-		return $sLogin;
+		return $bReturnLogin ? $sLogin : $sUserId;
 	}
 
 	/**

tests/php-unit-tests/unitary-tests/core/UserRightsTest.php

@@ -29,11 +29,11 @@ namespace Combodo\iTop\Test\UnitTest\Core;
 
 use Combodo\iTop\Test\UnitTest\ItopDataTestCase;
 use CoreCannotSaveObjectException;
-use CoreException;
 use DBObject;
 use DBObjectSearch;
 use DBObjectSet;
 use DeleteException;
+use Dict;
 use MetaModel;
 use UserLocal;
 use UserRights;
@@ -81,6 +81,65 @@ class UserRightsTest extends ItopDataTestCase
 		return $oUser;
 	}
 
+	public function testIsActionAllowedWithNonInstantiatedUserObject()
+	{
+		$oUser = $this->GivenUserWithProfiles('test1', [self::$aURP_Profiles['Configuration Manager']]); // not a readonly profile
+		$oAdminUser = $this->GivenUserWithProfiles('test2', [self::$aURP_Profiles['Administrator']]);
+		$oAdminUser->DBInsert();
+		$_SESSION = [];
+		UserRights::Login($oAdminUser->Get('login'));
+
+		self::assertTrue(UserRights::IsActionAllowed('Server', UR_ACTION_MODIFY, null, $oUser) === UR_ALLOWED_YES);
+	}
+
+	/**
+	 * @param array $aProfileIds
+	 * @param array $aShouldBeAllowedToSeeClass
+	 * @param array $aShouldBeAllowedToEditClass
+	 *
+	 * @return void
+	 * @throws \ArchivedObjectException
+	 * @throws \CoreCannotSaveObjectException
+	 * @throws \CoreException
+	 * @throws \CoreUnexpectedValue
+	 * @throws \CoreWarning
+	 * @throws \DictExceptionUnknownLanguage
+	 * @throws \MySQLException
+	 * @throws \OQLException
+	 * @dataProvider ReadOnlyProvider
+	 */
+	public function testReadOnlyUser(array $aProfileIds, array $aShouldBeAllowedToSeeClass, array $aShouldBeAllowedToEditClass): void
+	{
+
+		$oUser = $this->GivenUserWithProfiles('test1', $aProfileIds);
+		$oUser->DBInsert();
+		$_SESSION = [];
+		UserRights::Login($oUser->Get('login'));
+
+		$aClassesToTest = ['FunctionalCI', 'Ticket', 'ServiceFamily'];
+
+		foreach ($aClassesToTest as $sClass) {
+			$bShouldBeAllowedToSee = in_array($sClass, $aShouldBeAllowedToSeeClass);
+			$bIsAllowedReading = (bool)UserRights::IsActionAllowed($sClass, UR_ACTION_READ);
+
+			$this->assertSame(
+				$bShouldBeAllowedToSee,
+				$bIsAllowedReading,
+				"User with profiles ".implode(',', $aProfileIds)." should ".($bShouldBeAllowedToSee ? "" : "NOT ")."be allowed to see class $sClass"
+			);
+
+			$bShouldBeAllowedToEdit = in_array($sClass, $aShouldBeAllowedToEditClass);
+
+			$bIsAllowedEditing = (bool)UserRights::IsActionAllowed($sClass, UR_ACTION_MODIFY);
+
+			$this->assertSame(
+				$bIsAllowedEditing,
+				$bShouldBeAllowedToEdit,
+				"User with profiles ".implode(',', $aProfileIds)." should ".($bShouldBeAllowedToEdit ? "" : "NOT ")."be allowed to edit class $sClass"
+			);
+		}
+	}
+
 	protected function GivenUserWithProfiles(string $sLogin, array $aProfileIds): DBObject
 	{
 		$oProfiles = new \ormLinkSet(\UserLocal::class, 'profile_list', \DBObjectSet::FromScratch(\URP_UserProfile::class));
@@ -433,7 +492,7 @@ class UserRightsTest extends ItopDataTestCase
 		$oUser = $this->GivenUserWithProfiles('test1', [$iProfileId, 2]);
 
 		$this->expectException(CoreCannotSaveObjectException::class);
-		$this->expectExceptionMessage('Profile "Portal user" cannot be given to privileged Users (Administrators, SuperUsers and REST Services Users)');
+		$this->expectExceptionMessage(Dict::Format('Class:User/Error:PrivilegedUserMustHaveAccessToBackOffice', PORTAL_PROFILE_NAME));
 		$oUser->DBInsert();
 
 	}
@@ -572,4 +631,82 @@ class UserRightsTest extends ItopDataTestCase
 		$oUser = $this->InvokeNonPublicStaticMethod(UserRights::class, "FindUser", [$sLogin]);
 		static::assertNull($oUser, 'FindUser should return null when the login is unknown');
 	}
+
+	protected function ReadOnlyProvider(): array
+	{
+		return [
+			'CI' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5500,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'FunctionalCI',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'Tickets' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5501,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'Ticket',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'Catalog' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5502,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'ServiceFamily',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'CI and Tickets' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5500, 5501,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'FunctionalCI', 'Ticket',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'CI and Catalog' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5500, 5502,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'FunctionalCI', 'ServiceFamily',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'Tickets and Catalog' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5501, 5502,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'Ticket', 'ServiceFamily',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+			'Tickets and Catalog + profile Ccnfiguration Manager' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5501, 5502, 3,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'FunctionalCI', 'Ticket', 'ServiceFamily',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => ['FunctionalCI'],
+			],
+			'CI, Tickets and Catalog' => [
+				'ProfilesId' => [
+					5500, 5501, 5502,
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToSeeClasses' => [
+					'FunctionalCI', 'Ticket', 'ServiceFamily',
+				],
+				'ShouldBeAllowedToEditClasses' => [],
+			],
+		];
+	}
 }