N°5655 - Router: Improve robustness

* Change visibility from public to protected of methods for which it was not necessary
  * Change visibility from static to non-static of methods that could be used as such for easier testability
  * Cache available routes for better performances
  * Finish Router::GetRoutes() so we can use the available routes data to display them to the developers somewhere (ideally in the toolkit)
  * Improve unit tests
This commit is contained in:
Molkobain
2023-05-02 21:18:46 +02:00
parent 1945708c16
commit 3ce810ee99
2 changed files with 190 additions and 131 deletions

View File

@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ use Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Exception\RouteNotFoundException;
use ReflectionClass;
use ReflectionMethod;
use utils;
use SetupUtils;
/**
* Class Router
@@ -29,7 +30,7 @@ class Router
/**
* @return $this The singleton instance of the router
*/
public static function GetInstance()
public static function GetInstance(): Router
{
if (null === static::$oSingleton) {
static::$oSingleton = new static();
@@ -38,44 +39,6 @@ class Router
return static::$oSingleton;
}
/**
* @return array{0: string, 1: string} Array of available routes namespaces and their corresponding controllers (eg. ['object' => '\Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController', ...])
*/
public static function GetRoutesNamespaces(): array
{
$aRoutesNamespaces = [];
foreach (utils::GetClassesForInterface('Combodo\iTop\Controller\iController', '', ['[\\\\/]lib[\\\\/]', '[\\\\/]node_modules[\\\\/]', '[\\\\/]test[\\\\/]']) as $sControllerFQCN) {
$aRoutesNamespaces[$sControllerFQCN::ROUTE_NAMESPACE] = $sControllerFQCN;
}
return $aRoutesNamespaces;
}
/**
* @return array{0: string, 1: string} Array of available routes and their corresponding controllers (eg. ['object.modify' => '\Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController::OperationModify', ...])
* @throws \ReflectionException
*/
public static function GetRoutes(): array
{
$aRoutes = [];
foreach (static::GetRoutesNamespaces() as $sRouteNamespace => $sRouteControllerFQCN) {
$oReflectionClass = new ReflectionClass($sRouteControllerFQCN);
foreach ($oReflectionClass->getMethods(ReflectionMethod::IS_PUBLIC) as $oReflectionMethod) {
// Ignore non "operation" methods
$sPrefix = 'Operation';
$iPos = stripos($oReflectionMethod->name, $sPrefix);
if ($iPos !== 0) {
continue;
}
$sOperationName = substr($oReflectionMethod->name, $iPos + strlen($sPrefix));
$aRoutes[$sRouteNamespace.'.'.utils::ToSnakeCase($sOperationName)] = $sRouteControllerFQCN.'::'.$oReflectionMethod->name;
}
}
return $aRoutes;
}
/**********************/
/* Non-static methods */
/**********************/
@@ -85,7 +48,7 @@ class Router
*
* @return void
*/
private function __construct()
protected function __construct()
{
// Don't do anything, we don't want to be initialized
}
@@ -149,31 +112,104 @@ class Router
return $mResponse;
}
/**
* @return array{0: string, 1: array{
* namespace: string,
* operation: string,
* controller: string,
* description: string
* }
* } Array of available routes and their corresponding controllers (eg. [
* 'object.modify' => [ // Complete route code
* 'namespace' => 'object', // Route namespace
* 'operation' => 'modify', // Route operation
* 'controller' => '\Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController::OperationModify', // FQCN of the controller/method that handle the route
* 'description' => 'Handles display of a modification form for a datamodel object' // Text description of the route
* ],
* ...
* ])
* @throws \ReflectionException
*/
public function GetRoutes(): array
{
$aRoutes = [];
$bUseCache = false === utils::IsDevelopmentEnvironment();
$sCacheFilePath = $this->GetCacheFileAbsPath();
// Try to read from cache
if ($bUseCache) {
if (is_file($sCacheFilePath)) {
$aRoutes = include $sCacheFilePath;
}
}
// If no cache, force to re-scan for routes
if (count($aRoutes) === 0) {
foreach (utils::GetClassesForInterface('Combodo\iTop\Controller\iController', '', ['[\\\\/]lib[\\\\/]', '[\\\\/]node_modules[\\\\/]', '[\\\\/]test[\\\\/]']) as $sControllerFQCN) {
$sRouteNamespace = $sControllerFQCN::ROUTE_NAMESPACE;
// Ignore controller with no namespace
if (is_null($sRouteNamespace)) {
continue;
}
$oReflectionClass = new ReflectionClass($sControllerFQCN);
foreach ($oReflectionClass->getMethods(ReflectionMethod::IS_PUBLIC) as $oReflectionMethod) {
// Ignore non "operation" methods
$sPrefix = 'Operation';
$iPos = stripos($oReflectionMethod->name, $sPrefix);
if ($iPos !== 0) {
continue;
}
// eg. "OperationDoSomething"
$sMethodName = $oReflectionMethod->name;
// eg. "do_something"
$sRouteOperation = utils::ToSnakeCase(substr($oReflectionMethod->name, $iPos + strlen($sPrefix)));
$aRoutes[$sRouteNamespace . '.' . $sRouteOperation] = [
'namespace' => $sRouteNamespace,
'operation' => $sRouteOperation,
'controller' => $sControllerFQCN . '::' . $sMethodName,
'description' => $oReflectionMethod->getDocComment(),
];
}
}
}
// Save to cache
if ($bUseCache) {
$sCacheContent = "<?php\n\nreturn ".var_export($aRoutes, true).";";
SetupUtils::builddir(dirname($sCacheFilePath));
file_put_contents($sCacheFilePath, $sCacheContent);
}
return $aRoutes;
}
/**
* @param string $sRoute
*
* @return array{sControllerFQCN, sOperationMethodName}|null The FQCN controller and operation method matching $sRoute, null if no matching handler
*/
public function GetDispatchSpecsForRoute(string $sRoute)
protected function GetDispatchSpecsForRoute(string $sRoute)
{
$aRouteParts = $this->GetRouteParts($sRoute);
if (is_null($aRouteParts)) {
return null;
}
$sRouteNamespace = $aRouteParts['namespace'];
$sRouteOperation = $aRouteParts['operation'];
$sControllerFQCN = $this->FindControllerFromRouteNamespace($sRouteNamespace);
if (utils::IsNullOrEmptyString($sControllerFQCN)) {
$sRouteHandlerFQCN = $this->FindHandlerFromRoute($sRoute);
if (utils::IsNullOrEmptyString($sRouteHandlerFQCN)) {
return null;
}
$sOperationMethodName = $this->MakeOperationMethodNameFromOperation($sRouteOperation);
if (false === method_exists($sControllerFQCN, $sOperationMethodName)) {
// Extract controller and method names
$aParts = explode('::', $sRouteHandlerFQCN);
if (count($aParts) !== 2) {
return null;
}
return [$sControllerFQCN, $sOperationMethodName];
return [$aParts[0], $aParts[1]];
}
/**
@@ -181,7 +217,7 @@ class Router
*
* @return array{namespace: string, operation: string}|null Route parts (namespace and operation) if route can be parsed, null otherwise
*/
public function GetRouteParts(string $sRoute)
protected function GetRouteParts(string $sRoute)
{
if (utils::IsNullOrEmptyString($sRoute)) {
return null;
@@ -201,7 +237,7 @@ class Router
*
* @return string|null Namespace of the route (eg. "object" for "object.modify") if route can be parsed null otherwise
*/
public function GetRouteNamespace(string $sRoute): ?string
protected function GetRouteNamespace(string $sRoute): ?string
{
$mSeparatorPos = strripos($sRoute, '.', -1);
if (false === $mSeparatorPos) {
@@ -216,7 +252,7 @@ class Router
*
* @return string|null Operation of the route (eg. "modify" for "object.modify") if route can be parsed null otherwise
*/
public function GetRouteOperation(string $sRoute): ?string
protected function GetRouteOperation(string $sRoute): ?string
{
$mSeparatorPos = strripos($sRoute, '.', -1);
if (false === $mSeparatorPos) {
@@ -227,28 +263,23 @@ class Router
}
/**
* @param string $sRouteNamespace {@see static::$sRouteNamespace}
* @param string $sRouteToFind Route (eg. 'object.modify') to find the matching controler for
*
* @return string|null The FQCN of the controller matching the $sRouteNamespace, null if none matching.
* @return string|null The FQCN of the handler (controller class + operation, eg. "\Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController::OperationModify) matching $sRouteNamespace, null if none matching.
*/
protected function FindControllerFromRouteNamespace(string $sRouteNamespace): ?string
protected function FindHandlerFromRoute(string $sRouteToFind): ?string
{
foreach (static::GetRoutesNamespaces() as $sControllerRouteNamespace => $sControllerFQCN) {
if ($sControllerRouteNamespace === $sRouteNamespace) {
return $sControllerFQCN;
foreach ($this->GetRoutes() as $sRoute => $aRouteData) {
if ($sRoute === $sRouteToFind) {
return $aRouteData['controller'];
}
}
return null;
}
/**
* @param string $sOperation
*
* @return string The method name for the $sOperation regarding the convention
*/
protected function MakeOperationMethodNameFromOperation(string $sOperation): string
protected function GetCacheFileAbsPath(): string
{
return 'Operation'.utils::ToCamelCase($sOperation);
return utils::GetCachePath().'router/available-routes.php';
}
}

View File

@@ -124,29 +124,13 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
*
* @return void
*/
// public function testCanDispatchRoute(string $sRoute, $bExpectedResult): void
// {
// $oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
// $bTestedResult = $oRouter->CanDispatchRoute($sRoute);
//
// $sRouteNamespace = $oRouter->GetRouteNamespace($sRoute);
// $sRouteOperation = $oRouter->GetRouteOperation($sRoute);
// $aRouteParts = $oRouter->GetRouteParts($sRoute);
// $sControllerFQCN = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(get_class($oRouter), 'FindControllerFromRouteNamespace', $oRouter, ['object']);
// $sMethodName = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(get_class($oRouter), 'MakeOperationMethodNameFromOperation', $oRouter, ['modify']);
// $aDispatchSpecs = $oRouter->GetDispatchSpecsForRoute($sRoute);
//
//$this->debug($sRoute);
//$this->debug($sRouteNamespace);
//$this->debug($sRouteOperation);
//$this->debug($aRouteParts);
//$this->debug($sControllerFQCN);
//$this->debug($sMethodName);
//$this->debug(is_callable([$sControllerFQCN, $sMethodName]) ? 'true' : 'false');
//$this->debug($aDispatchSpecs);
//$this->debug($bTestedResult);
// $this->assertEquals($bExpectedResult, $bTestedResult, "Dispatch capability for '$sRoute' was not the expected one. Got ".var_export($bTestedResult, true).", expected ".var_export($bExpectedResult, true));
// }
public function testCanDispatchRoute(string $sRoute, $bExpectedResult): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$bTestedResult = $oRouter->CanDispatchRoute($sRoute);
$this->assertEquals($bExpectedResult, $bTestedResult, "Dispatch capability for '$sRoute' was not the expected one. Got ".var_export($bTestedResult, true).", expected ".var_export($bExpectedResult, true));
}
public function CanDispatchRouteProvider(): array
{
@@ -166,6 +150,84 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
];
}
/**
* @dataProvider GetRoutesProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::GetRoutes
*
* @param string $sRoute
* @param bool $bShouldBePresent
*
* @return void
* @throws \ReflectionException
*/
public function testGetRoutes(string $sRoute, bool $bShouldBePresent): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$aTestedRoutes = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(Router::class, 'GetRoutes', $oRouter, []);
$bIsPresent = array_key_exists($sRoute, $aTestedRoutes);
$this->assertEquals($bShouldBePresent, $bIsPresent, "Route '$sRoute' was not expected amongst the available routes.");
}
public function GetRoutesProvider(): array
{
return [
'Valid route' => [
'object.modify',
true,
],
// eg. a route from a controller that has no ROUTE_NAMESPACE
'Invalid route' => [
'.save_state',
false,
],
];
}
/**
* @dataProvider GetRoutePartsProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::GetRouteParts
*
* @param string $sRoute
* @param array|null $aExpectedParts
*
* @return void
*/
public function testGetRouteParts(string $sRoute, ?array $aExpectedParts): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$aTestedParts = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(Router::class, 'GetRouteParts', $oRouter, [$sRoute]);
$this->assertEquals($aExpectedParts, $aTestedParts, "Parts found for '$sRoute' were not the expected ones. Got '".print_r($aTestedParts, true)."', expected '".print_r($aExpectedParts, true)."'.");
}
public function GetRoutePartsProvider(): array
{
return [
'Empty route' => [
'',
null,
],
// eg. controller implmenting iController but without the ROUTE_NAMESPACE content. This is for BC compatibility
'Route with no namespace' => [
'.some_operation',
null,
],
'Route with no operation' => [
'some_namespace.',
null,
],
'Valid route' => [
'some_namespace.some_operation',
['namespace' => 'some_namespace', 'operation' => 'some_operation'],
],
'Valid route with deep namespace' => [
'some.deep.namespace.some_operation',
['namespace' => 'some.deep.namespace', 'operation' => 'some_operation'],
],
];
}
/**
* @dataProvider GetRouteNamespaceProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::GetRouteNamespace
@@ -178,7 +240,7 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
public function testGetRouteNamespace(string $sRoute, ?string $sExpectedNamespace): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$sTestedNamespace = $oRouter->GetRouteNamespace($sRoute);
$sTestedNamespace = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(Router::class, 'GetRouteNamespace', $oRouter, [$sRoute]);
$this->assertEquals($sExpectedNamespace, $sTestedNamespace, "Namespace found for '$sRoute' was not the expected one. Got '$sTestedNamespace', expected '$sExpectedNamespace'.");
}
@@ -213,7 +275,7 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
public function testGetRouteOperation(string $sRoute, ?string $sExpectedOperation): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$sTestedOperation = $oRouter->GetRouteOperation($sRoute);
$sTestedOperation = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(Router::class, 'GetRouteOperation', $oRouter, [$sRoute]);
$this->assertEquals($sExpectedOperation, $sTestedOperation, "Operation found for '$sRoute' was not the expected one. Got '$sTestedOperation', expected '$sExpectedOperation'.");
}
@@ -237,30 +299,28 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
}
/**
* @dataProvider FindControllerFromRouteNamespaceProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::FindControllerFromRouteNamespace
* @dataProvider FindHandlerFromRouteProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::FindHandlerFromRoute
*
* @param string $sRouteNamespace
* @param string $sExpectedControllerFQCN
* @param string $sExpectedHandlerFQCN
*
* @return void
*/
public function testFindControllerFromRouteNamespace(string $sRoute, ?string $sExpectedControllerFQCN): void
public function testFindHandlerFromRoute(string $sRoute, ?string $sExpectedHandlerFQCN): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$sRouteNamespace = $oRouter->GetRouteNamespace($sRoute);
$sTestedHandlerFQCN = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(Router::class, 'FindHandlerFromRoute', $oRouter, [$sRoute]);
$sTestedControllerFQCN = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(get_class($oRouter), 'FindControllerFromRouteNamespace', $oRouter, [$sRouteNamespace]);
$this->assertEquals($sExpectedControllerFQCN, $sTestedControllerFQCN, "Controller found for '$sRouteNamespace' was not the expected one. Got '$sTestedControllerFQCN', expected '$sExpectedControllerFQCN'.");
$this->assertEquals($sExpectedHandlerFQCN, $sTestedHandlerFQCN, "Handler found for '$sRoute' was not the expected one. Got '$sTestedHandlerFQCN', expected '$sExpectedHandlerFQCN'.");
}
public function FindControllerFromRouteNamespaceProvider(): array
public function FindHandlerFromRouteProvider(): array
{
return [
'Object controller' => [
'object.modify',
'Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController',
'Combodo\iTop\Controller\Base\Layout\ObjectController::OperationModify',
],
'Unknown controller' => [
'something_that_should_not_exist_in_the_default_package.foo',
@@ -268,36 +328,4 @@ class RouterTest extends ItopTestCase
],
];
}
/**
* @dataProvider GetOperationMethodNameFromRouteOperationProvider
* @covers \Combodo\iTop\Service\Router\Router::MakeOperationMethodNameFromOperation
*
* @param string $sRoute
* @param string $sExpectedMethodName
*
* @return void
*/
public function testGetOperationMethodNameFromRouteOperation(string $sRoute, string $sExpectedMethodName): void
{
$oRouter = Router::GetInstance();
$aRouteParts = $oRouter->GetRouteParts($sRoute);
$sTestedMethodName = $this->InvokeNonPublicMethod(get_class($oRouter), 'MakeOperationMethodNameFromOperation', $oRouter, [$aRouteParts['operation']]);
$this->assertEquals($sExpectedMethodName, $sTestedMethodName, "Operation method name '".$aRouteParts['operation']."' was not matching the expected one. Got '$sTestedMethodName', expected '$sExpectedMethodName'.");
}
public function GetOperationMethodNameFromRouteOperationProvider(): array
{
return [
'Simple operation' => [
'object.modify',
'OperationModify',
],
'Operation with an underscore' => [
'object.apply_modify',
'OperationApplyModify',
],
];
}
}